website statistics
feed
Home arrow News arrow Legal/General News arrow Judge opens Pandora’s box
Advertisement
Judge opens Pandora’s box PDF Print E-mail
Wednesday, 25 June 2008 07:09am

Datuk Ian Chin Please click here to download the entire notes of proceedings
Justice Chin says it again: Mahathir made veiled threats

©The Borneo Post (Used by permission)
by Raymond Tan

Ian Chin details humiliation at boot camp to soften them to take orders of previous administration

SIBU: High Court Judge Datuk Ian Chin continued to make explosive disclosures in the Sarikei parliamentary election petition mention yesterday, exposing how judges sent to the boot camp were made to go through punishment and humiliation so that they would be softened to take orders for the benefit of the former administration.

Chin delivered a 16-page statement after the one he made on June 9 that astounded the nation. It was alleged that Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad had exerted undue influence upon the judiciary to make it decide in the government’s favour.

Chin said he was sent to a boot camp for that.

In yesterday’s statement, Chin went on to reveal further details of what had happened in the camp.

Chin said for the participants, the objective was “to make us take orders and that is why apart from what I have said earlier in the last sitting, a junior officer was made our leader, from whom we have to take orders, and one Sessions Court judge who disagreed with that was made to publicly apologise on a podium to his junior officer leader”.

Chin added that “another method was to chisel away the view we held of how independent we should be in our job as High Court judges, and this they did by punishing or humiliating a High Court judge by making him carry a brick all the time after he broke the egg which each of us must carry wherever we went, including marching.”

Incidentally, he said: “You surrendered your wallet, your air ticket and handphone when you checked into the camp, and you cannot go anywhere, as it is in an isolated place, and you cannot leave for anywhere, as there is no transport.

“You are totally cut off from the outside world, with no newspapers or television.”

He said only selected news were conveyed to them then for the purpose of sampling reaction, like the news that a certain party had won a by-election, which elicited some applause from some young officers.

He said two of the judges left, one because of illness and the other because of his wife’s illness.

“Everyone who was not otherwise sick had to remain, and we all did save for the duo, with each given a certificate after the end of the stay.”

During the mention which started at 4pm, Chin started by saying he had prepared in advance yesterday’s statement and had emailed a copy each to the lawyers.

“In case I meet with an accidental death, both counsels have agreed that this statement would be regarded as having been pronounced in court,” he said.

Chin also mentioned in his statement about him being condemned for his June 9 statement with allegations made that he took the opportunity to speak up because he thought Dr Mahathir was responsible for blocking his promotion.

He went on to say that he had never wanted such a promotion, as it was his wish and that of his wife to return to Sabah so that they could be with their children.

He also mentioned about the alleged veiled threat by Dr Mahathir that he disclosed in his June 9 statement. He then went on to talk of the events in the boot camp.

Chin ended by saying that he had never wanted a promotion, “not before, now or in the future, nor any appointment after his retirement”.

“What do I get out of all this, knowing very well that I will be the target for vilification? It is this: I must be able to sleep well after I retire, knowing that I have done all I can, like all the crucified judges before me, to tell Malaysians the danger they are in, regarding the state of the judiciary.”

Hearing will resume July 7.

Comments (7)Add Comment
FUTURE MALAYSIANS DESERVE BETTER
written by Stephen Tan Ban Cheng, Wednesday, June 25 2008 08:21 am

Indeed, we Malaysians are in grave danger and will continue to be in this state if any member of our judiciary is treated the way Ian Chin says he was.

From New Zealand, where I read my copy of May Day For Justice which stated that the judiciary has been relegated as just one of the many departments of state.

I view this as a step backwards as ipso facto it virtually demolishes the concept of the separation of powers where the legislative, the executive and the judiciary are separate but equal arms of a democratic government.

If memory serves me right, this adverse view was contained in my first written assignment that is still on call as a model answer in our law school library.

Somehow, amidst all these revelations, my decision to take a breather in a foreign country appears to be vindicated because deep down, I knew that something was amiss, although I could not at that stage define what that "something" was.

We Malaysians may take these revelations like ducks taking so much water or regard this as something worth reflecting about.

Has damage been done? If so, what do we do? Whatever our reaction, we owe it to future generations to leave this country a better one than when we found it. Anything less is a betrayal ... and future Malaysians deserve better.

Stephen Tan Ban Cheng

How now Datuk Zaid?
written by Visvanathan Murugiah, Wednesday, June 25 2008 10:23 am

Dear Datuk,

Still say no need for investigations ? This article is down right depressing and damning of the Malaysian Judiciary.I still say we need to clean out ALL the dirt from under the carpet first before we can finally declare that all is well and good with the judiciary.

Visvanathan Murugiah smilies/angry.gif

WHO IS LYING OR MISLEADING US?
written by Stephen Tan Ban Cheng, Wednesday, June 25 2008 11:19 am

Dr Mahathir Mohamad said that Ian Chin left the "boot camp" without completing it. Chin subsequently said that he completed the course.

Who is lying? The former Prime Minister or the sitting High Court Judge?

Stephen Tan Ban Cheng

What do I believe
written by Yeo Yang Poh, Wednesday, June 25 2008 12:17 pm

History is seldom by unanimity. There are bound to be assertions and denials.

Often it comes down to a matter of informed and reasoned belief, based on the credibility or otherwise of the diverse assertions, viewed in the totality of the available facts, circumstances and allegations.

On that basis, I believe Justice Chin.

A full enquiry will help record history accurately. But there appears to be no real political will to do that. So we are left with our respective beliefs, formed, it is hoped, in an informed and reasoned manner.

I believe Justice Chin. Because of that, I also deeply respect him.

What do you believe?

Yeo Yang Poh

TRUTH IS A POINT ON A HILL ...
written by Stephen Tan Ban Cheng, Wednesday, June 25 2008 01:14 pm

My Yeo

If truth is a point on a hill from where one stands to look at things, for some people, it may well mean standing at many points!

With such people, things get a lot more complicated than they appear.

Stephen Tan Ban Cheng

separation of powers? what is that?
written by Lim Chong Leong, Wednesday, June 25 2008 02:04 pm

What I understand about the government structure in Malaysia after some almost 18 years of practice is this: The King will act upon the advice of the PM. The PM will appoint and promote judges. The Speaker will act under the direction of the minister in the PM's department. The CJ reports to that same minister without portfolio.

What is this separation of powers concept?

Lim Chong Leong

Boot-camp? And for judges?
written by Teo Siew Chin, Wednesday, June 25 2008 02:58 pm

"Dr Mahathir Mohamad said that Ian Chin left the "boot camp" without completing it. Chin subsequently said that he completed the course. Who is lying? The former Prime Minister or the sitting High Court Judge?"
----------------------

Dear Mr Stephen Tan

You reckon the other attendees of this camp will recollect whether any of them left without completing the course?

A boot-camp for judges!!
What will they come up with next?!
A boot-camp for lawyers?

Teo Siew Chin


Write comment
You must be logged in to a comment. Please register if you do not have an account yet.

busy
 
< Prev   Next >
Username Password
Remember Me | Register | Lost Password?

PM to decide within two days



show last 4hrs - 24hrs