website statistics
feed
Home
Advertisement
Malaysian Bar Forum  


The day Free Speech was stabbed a little deeper - 2008/09/24 09:50 I was tempted to say that Free Speech is dead after reading about RPK detention at Kamunting, but I told myself that the fact that I am writing this Forum posting on the Bar website itself means some kind of free speech exist. I just hope the webmaster dont place this under the "registered member's only" list.

But the fact is, with RPK detention, the heart and soul of free speech in Malaysia was stabbed and it was stabbed deeper than usual, this time. For where is the danger of RPK's website? We dont see news of "rusuhan" or anxiety among Malaysians. No news from Kulim or Tumpat of Muslims being angry with RPK. NO news from PJ or Kuching of Malaysians feeling insecure due to national threat.

Syed Hamid Albar actually stated “His articles could arouse anger among Muslims,” quoted in the online version of the Star. See:-

http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2008/9/24/nation/2104063&sec=nation

In that report, Syed Hamid actually claimed that the police investigated on RPK website and recommended arrest as RPK ridiculed Islam.

RPK himself is a Muslim, and he is purportedly questioning Islam. How is that a National threat? How did he undermine National Security? There are laws available to prosecute him, and it is in the Penal Code. The Penal Code provides prosecution, if one is disrespectful to a religion. Go check on Penal Code when you have the time, and you will find the provision I am talking about there.

So if we have a specific law to charge RPK if he is guilty of that offence, why instead he is now under ISA arrest?

It is all too coincidence that RPK's website got attention after he uploaded comments about Altantuya's case. Suddenly he is a threat therafter. He attacked our Najib to be involved and claimed to have much evidence in support.

Is ISA used when one's position in the Government under threat? Is ISA used to protect the Government? I am tempted to say that the current Government themselves, is a threat to Malaysia. We do not know who is running the Country as the current Government seems to have a fixation for Anwar. When he say something, UMNO jumps. He goes to Court, major road blocks and checks at Court. He claims to have the MPs to cross over, BN send MPs to Taiwan. etc etc.

And not only that, when Mahathir talks about pegging, Najib immediately say no.

What kind of governance is this? Who is running the country? Are we running on auto-cruise?

Everyday we read news about politics, Anwar, Najib, Pak Lah etc. And to add to the depression, we have poor girls kidnapped and killed. What is the Government doing about poor Police standard (IPCMC?). Any news of investment? What happened about Iskandar Development and all those Corridors?

Now, we have a man who was running a website, arrested under ISA, when you and I can still have teh tarik at night, without any feeling of fear that the National Security is under threat.


richard wee
  | | The administrator has disabled public write access.
Re:The day Free Speech was stabbed a little deeper - 2008/09/25 01:53 I agree with you sdr Richard. One can no longer have teh tarik in our favourite mamak shop talking about politics and religion because at any one time, if it touches on some raw nerves, I could be spending time serving my detention under ISA. Definitely not enjoying the less than RM5.00 a day food allocation.

When did the government start seeing it fit to arrest people? Sorry, I ought to rephrase that, they have always SEE IT FIT to arrest people. RPK has been arrested under ISA and we know that it is definitely not because of the religious issues but because he had crossed path with many influencial men, inviting their wrath. Go for defamation then or if necessary take an injunction to prevent further publication of such 'stories', isn't that what everyone of us have to do? Unfortunately civillians like us do not have the backing of ISA to be used against individuals that we do not like...

Ng Chung Yee
  | | The administrator has disabled public write access.


Please abide by the Forum Rules at all times.
Username Password
Remember Me | Register | Lost Password?

Suhakam: Cops guilty of excessive force



View Full Calendar