|
©The
Sun (Used by permission)
by Llew-Ann Phang
KUALA LUMPUR (Oct 29, 2007): The three-man panel
investigating the authenticity of a video clip purportedly containing a
telephone conversation involving judicial appointments between a senior lawyer
and a "Datuk" met for almost five hours at its second meeting today, and
reported that no witnesses have approached it.
With the Nov 9 deadline for it to submit a report fast coming up, panel head Tan
Sri Haidar Mohd Noor told reporters today there is still time for witnesses to
come forward.
"We will see how it goes. Time (is) already short and we have a time frame to
work on," he said.
The former chief judge of Malaya said no one has approached the panel’s
secretariat – the Prime Minister’s Office's legal division – to give evidence on
the recording’s authenticity despite the assurance from the premier himself that
witnesses will be given protection.
The panel – also comprising former court of appeal judge Datuk Mahadev Shankar
and National Service Training Council chairman Tan Sri Lee Lam Thye was also
accompanied by secretariat head and PM’s Office legal division director-general
Datuk Abdullah Sani Ab Hamid.
It met with Attorney-General Tan Sri Abdul Gani Patail and Inspector-General of
Police Tan Sri Musa Hassan at its second meeting, held at the Malaysian Human
Rights Commission (Suhakam).
ACA deputy director-general of operations Datuk Abu Kassim Mohamed, who arrived
with Gani and Musa at 11.25am, stayed for the rest of the meeting with his team
of investigating officers.
Gani and Musa left almost an hour later.
Special Tasks Unit head Sazali Salbi, who heads the ACA investigation team, and
two digital forensic experts from CyberSecurity Malaysia (formerly known as
National ICT Security and Emergency Response Centre) including digital forensics
head Asmawi Fadillah Mohd Ariffin were present to adduce evidence.
However, Haidar did not reveal the panel’s findings, saying they have to report
to the government first.
"I will see to it that it (the report) should be ready by the time set by the
government," he said.
On strict conditions laid down by Mahadev, three members from the steering
committee for the Coalition of Free the Judiciary - namely Lateefah Koya, Eric
Paulson and Tian Chua - were allowed only 10 minutes during the proceedings to
present the panel with their second memorandum and raise their objections to the
panel’s appointment.
The Coalition again called for the establishment of a Royal Commission to look
into the matter, especially into corruption within the judiciary, and again
questioned Haidar’s interests as the chairman of the panel as he ruled in favour
of Datuk V.K. Lingam – the lawyer said to be in the clip – in a defamation case
previously.
Haidar, in replying to questions about their allegations said: "Have they all
read the judgment? To me my conscience is clear. I was not under any influence."
In Petaling Jaya, Deputy Prime Minister Datuk Seri Najib Abdul Razak said the
government will decide the fate of the three-man panel after it receives the
report from the panel.
"When we hear the report from the panel, then we will decide," he said, when
asked whether the panel would be disbanded if no one came foward to give
information on the video.
Yesterday, Minister in the Prime Minister's Department Datuk Seri Mohamed Nazri
Aziz was quoted as saying that it would be a "case closed" if no one volunteered
information to the panel by the time the deadline expired.
 |
News 
Subscribe to this comment's feed
list of participants.refugee law seminar
